From the Albany Times Union, New York

Turtles saved from soup pot

Officials seize diamondback terrapins, prized by Chinese for reputed medicinal qualities

 

By COLIN McDONALD, Staff writer
First published: Tuesday, January 3, 2006

BETHLEHEM -- Nine diamondback terrapins seized from a local Asian food market are being held in two large plastic tubs at the state wildlife pathology lab in Delmar pending an investigation into their origins, state wildlife pathologist Ward Stone said Monday.

The saltwater turtles are valued in traditional Chinese culture for their reputed medicinal value as a treatment for acne and cancer when consumed as a soup or broth.

 

 

Department of Environmental Conservation enforcement officers seized the turtles at the Asian Food Market on Colvin Avenue on Friday.

The reptiles, whose coastal habitat ranges from Cape Cod to Texas, are classified as a species of concern in New York. Since 1990, it has been illegal in the state to harvest them during their spring and early summer nesting season or to sell any individual animal shorter than 4 inches or longer than 7.

"Our regulations were passed because we did not know how large the harvest was, but we did know a large number were being sold in the fish markets," said Alvin Breisch, the DEC's amphibian and reptile specialist.

Only two people reported catching terrapins last year, Breisch said. Because the number of turtles appearing in New York markets is hundreds of times greater than the reported catch, it is assumed the animals are being imported from other states or taken without a permit.

The terrapins confiscated in Albany on Friday were all well over 7 inches, Stone said.

He said three of the nine females now at his lab have tags that he believes were placed on the shells as part of a research project in Maryland. If that is the case, he said, they will be inspected for any pathogens, returned to Maryland and released into the wild. The other animals will either be used for research or donated to a zoo.

"I'm not sure what will happen to them," Stone said. "But they will not be sold and eaten by people."

During a visit to the Asian Food Market on Monday afternoon, a milk crate contained about a dozen turtles that appeared to be diamondback terrapins for sale at $5 each. Most of them were longer than the 7-inch limit. When asked about the turtles, people working at the market said they were not able to comment.

Terrapin soup was popular in stylish New York restaurants in the 19th century, but the species was decimated by the 1920s and the item disappeared from menus. After that, the reptiles, which live in saltwater bays and estuaries, made a slow comeback in New York.

Famous for their big eyes and colorful shells, their popularity as pets and food has exploded over the past decade, leaving conservationists and government officials concerned for their future.

According to the Terrapin Institute, a nonprofit research group based in Maryland, the market for terrapins in the Northeast has grown 400 percent over the last decade. Faced with loss of habitat and lethal threats ranging vehicles to pollution to boat propellers, the population is again at risk.

Steve Chan, owner of the Plum Blossom restaurant in Troy, recalled eating turtle soup at his parents' home as a teenager to treat his acne. He said some Chinese people believe the soup also has the ability to fight cancer and increase people's longevity. "Because the turtle can live so long, they might hope to live longer. It's an older generation thing," Chan said.

Stone's concern about the sale of turtles also extends to human consumption and interaction with the turtles because it is unknown what diseases they carry or what chemicals they have been exposed to. They are known to prefer the warm waters discharged by industrial and power plants.

Terrapins are also popular among animal lovers who buy and then release them to the wild, but Stone said they are rarely put into an environment where they can survive and they are an ideal carrier of diseases that could harm other species living in those areas.

McDonald can be reached at 454-5441 or by e-mail at cmcdonald@timesunion.com.

 

 

All Times Union materials copyright 1996-2006, Capital Newspapers Division of The Hearst Corporation, Albany, N.Y.